AI POLICY

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Policy in Research and Scholarly Publishing

In line with its commitment to promoting academic integrity, protecting intellectual property rights, and ensuring the quality of published scholarly research, Thawabetna Journal adopts a comprehensive policy governing the use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) technologies and tools throughout the processes of research preparation, manuscript submission, editorial review, peer review, and publication.

The Journal recognizes the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence technologies and their potential to support researchers in various academic activities. However, the use of such technologies must adhere to the principles of transparency, scientific responsibility, academic integrity, and ethical scholarly publishing.

This policy aims to promote the responsible use of AI tools, safeguard the originality of scholarly work, protect the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts and research data, and maintain confidence in the Journal's editorial and peer-review processes.

1. Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Authors

Thawabetna Journal permits the use of artificial intelligence tools as supplementary resources in preparing scholarly manuscripts, provided that such use complies with established standards of academic integrity and the Journal's publication ethics policies.

Authors are required to comply with the following provisions:

1.1. Disclosure and Transparency

Authors must clearly disclose any use of AI tools in the preparation, editing, data processing, analysis, or generation of any component of their submitted manuscripts.

1.2. Identification of AI Tools

The disclosure statement must specify the full name of the AI tool or application, its version number where available, the nature of its use, its intended purpose, and its contribution to the preparation of the manuscript.

1.3. Location of Disclosure

The AI disclosure statement must be included in the Methods section or the Acknowledgments section, depending on the nature of the AI assistance provided. This information enables the Editorial Board to assess compliance with the Journal's ethical publishing standards.

1.4. Scientific Accountability

Authors bear full responsibility for the accuracy, validity, originality, and reliability of all information, data, analyses, findings, conclusions, and references presented in their manuscripts, including material prepared or modified with AI assistance.

1.5. Verification of AI-Generated Content

Authors must critically review and verify all AI-generated outputs, including factual statements, citations, references, interpretations, and analytical results. The inclusion of fabricated references, unsupported claims, or inaccurate information is strictly prohibited.

1.6. Research Originality and Integrity

AI tools must not be used to facilitate plagiarism, fabricate or falsify research data, manipulate findings, or misrepresent AI-generated content as original scholarly contributions without appropriate verification, review, and disclosure.

1.7. Authorship Eligibility

AI tools and systems cannot be listed as authors or co-authors of scholarly manuscripts. Authorship is restricted to individuals who meet recognized authorship criteria and can assume full scientific and ethical responsibility for the published work.

1.8. Protection of Confidential Research Data

Authors must not upload confidential information, protected personal data, or restricted research materials to AI platforms unless appropriate authorization and sufficient safeguards for data privacy and security are in place.

The Editorial Board of Thawabetna Journal reserves the right to request additional information regarding the use of AI tools and to determine whether submitted manuscripts comply with the Journal's academic integrity and publication requirements.

2. Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Editors and Editorial Board Members

Editors and Editorial Board members of Thawabetna Journal are responsible for maintaining the quality, integrity, confidentiality, and independence of the editorial and publication processes.

Accordingly, the following provisions apply:

2.1. Confidentiality of Manuscripts

All submitted manuscripts, research documents, and supplementary materials must be treated as confidential scholarly materials. Their contents must not be disclosed or shared with unauthorized individuals, institutions, or technological services.

2.2. Prohibition on Uploading Unpublished Manuscripts

Editors are strictly prohibited from uploading or entering any part of an unpublished manuscript into AI platforms or applications, including text, images, tables, figures, datasets, and supplementary files.

2.3. Intellectual Property Protection

Editors must respect authors' intellectual property rights and protect unpublished research materials against unauthorized access, processing, storage, or reuse, particularly by AI services that may retain submitted information or use it for model training.

2.4. Permitted Editorial Uses

AI tools may be used for limited administrative or editorial support tasks, such as improving the clarity and linguistic quality of general editorial communications, provided that no confidential information or unpublished research content is disclosed.

2.5. Prior Authorization

Any use of AI tools for editorial purposes beyond previously authorized activities requires prior approval from the Editor-in-Chief and must comply with applicable confidentiality and data protection requirements.

2.6. Independence of Editorial Decisions

AI tools must not independently determine whether a manuscript should be accepted, rejected, or revised. Editorial decisions must remain under the responsibility of qualified human editors and the Editorial Board, in accordance with the Journal's established evaluation procedures.

2.7. Professional Accountability

Editors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, integrity, and ethical compliance of all editorial activities supported by AI technologies.

These provisions are intended to protect editorial independence, maintain scholarly standards, and preserve the trust of authors and reviewers in the Journal's publication process.

3. Policy on the Use of Artificial Intelligence by Peer Reviewers

Thawabetna Journal considers independent and specialized peer review essential to maintaining the quality, originality, and credibility of published scholarly research.

Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, subject-area expertise, and research experience. They are expected to provide independent, objective, and evidence-based evaluations.

Reviewers must comply with the following requirements:

3.1. Independence of Peer Review

Reviewers must conduct their assessments independently and must not rely on AI tools to analyze, summarize, evaluate, or draw conclusions regarding submitted manuscripts or any part of their content.

3.2. Prohibition on Sharing Manuscripts

Reviewers are strictly prohibited from uploading unpublished manuscripts or related materials to AI platforms, including manuscript text, research proposals, tables, figures, datasets, appendices, and supporting documents.

3.3. Confidentiality Obligations

Reviewers must protect all information and research materials accessed during the peer-review process and must not disclose, distribute, or use such materials for unauthorized purposes.

3.4. Limited Linguistic Assistance

Reviewers may use AI tools solely to improve the linguistic clarity and readability of comments they have independently prepared, provided that no confidential information, manuscript excerpts, or unpublished research materials are entered into such tools.

3.5. Responsibility for Review Reports

Reviewers remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, objectivity, and scientific validity of their assessments, regardless of any permitted technological assistance.

3.6. Prohibition of Automated Peer Review

Reviewers must not delegate the preparation of peer-review reports, scientific evaluations, or recommendations concerning manuscript acceptance, rejection, or revision to AI systems.

The Editorial Board reserves the right to take appropriate measures in response to violations of this policy, including removing reviewers from ongoing assignments or excluding them from future peer-review activities.

4. Disclosure of Artificial Intelligence Use

To promote transparency and accountability in scholarly publishing, Thawabetna Journal requires authors to disclose relevant uses of artificial intelligence technologies during manuscript preparation.

The disclosure statement must include:

  • The name of the AI tool or application used.

  • The developer or provider of the tool, where known.

  • The version number, if available.

  • The nature and extent of AI involvement.

  • The purpose for which the tool was used.

  • Confirmation that the authors reviewed and verified the AI-assisted content and accept full responsibility for its accuracy and originality.

Suggested AI Disclosure Statement

"The author(s) declare that they used [AI tool name and version] for [specific purpose] during the preparation of this manuscript. All AI-assisted outputs were critically reviewed and verified, and the author(s) assume full scientific and ethical responsibility for the accuracy, originality, findings, and conclusions of the research."

Declaration of No AI Use

Where no generative AI tools were used, authors may include the following statement:

"The author(s) declare that no generative artificial intelligence tools were used in preparing the scholarly content of this manuscript."

5. Accountability and Policy Violations

Thawabetna Journal emphasizes that the use of artificial intelligence technologies does not diminish the individual or institutional responsibilities associated with ethical research and scholarly publishing.

Where undisclosed, inappropriate, or unethical use of AI tools is identified, or where fabricated, falsified, or plagiarized content is discovered, the Editorial Board may take appropriate measures according to the nature and severity of the violation.

Such measures may include:

  1. Requesting additional information, explanations, or supporting documentation from the authors.

  2. Returning the manuscript to the authors for necessary corrections or clarification.

  3. Rejecting the manuscript at any stage of the editorial or peer-review process where serious violations of academic integrity are established.

  4. Issuing a correction, editorial notice, or retraction of a published article where substantial violations are confirmed, in accordance with the Journal's applicable procedures.

  5. Taking appropriate professional action against editors or reviewers who violate confidentiality requirements or ethical standards relating to the use of artificial intelligence.

All allegations of misconduct shall be assessed fairly, with due consideration of the available evidence and the circumstances of each case.

6. Final Provisions

This Artificial Intelligence Policy forms an integral part of the publication ethics framework adopted by Thawabetna Journal.

All authors, editors, Editorial Board members, and peer reviewers involved in manuscript submission, assessment, editing, and publication are expected to comply with its provisions.

The Editorial Board reserves the right to review and update this policy in response to technological developments, emerging ethical challenges, and internationally recognized standards for responsible research and scholarly publishing.

Thawabetna Journal affirms that artificial intelligence technologies should serve as supplementary tools supporting scholarly research and communication. They must not replace independent critical thinking, original academic contribution, professional judgment, or the ethical responsibility of researchers and publishing professionals.


Thawabetna Peer-Reviewed Scientific Journal

Published by the Palestinian National Constants Commission